Wednesday, August 28, 2019

I’D RATHER BE SMART THAN LUCKY, BUT I’D PREFER TO BE LUCKY AND SMART


8/28/19

I wrote this letter to the Wall Street Journal at the end of July in response to a weekend edition Opinion piece.   The letter wasn’t published.  Since its subject matter is timeless, it’s not too late to share it with my readers.


7/27/19

I agree with Frayda Levin’s exasperation at the attribution, so prevalent in today’s increasingly simple-minded society, of success to luck.   (“Lady Luck Didn’t Make Me Successful,” Opinion, 7/27-7/28/19)   Such attribution simply feeds the wrong-headed envy that leads to idiotic policy and furthers the social division on which politicians thrive.  However, I would be a little more nuanced, and a little less cocksure, about the role of luck and point out that luck is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for success.

In the many years I have spent working, and simply living, I have seen those who rely exclusively or largely on luck fail miserably.   At the same time, I have seen many people who work diligently, intelligently, and nearly incessantly and still fail to achieve success.   There was something that wasn’t working for them.   Call it luck, serendipity, or even blessing, though the last would involve ascribing motivations to the Almighty that are baffling and far beyond the scope of this subject.   In any case, these people, who had worked as hard as anybody, still failed to achieve success.   They were simply unlucky.

I have also noticed over the course of a long life the positive relationship between the amount of luck from which a person has benefited and the intensity of his insistence that luck had nothing to do with his success.

No comments:

Post a Comment